My 2010-2019 picks:
Offense
QB
Mike Piatkowski (2011) --Although at times outshined by his successors, Andy Rice and Grant Kraemer, Piatkowski is the obvious choice. He was a three-year starter who finished as Drake's record holder in both season and career passing yards.
RB
Steve Platek (2010) --Recruited as a quarterback, he became a starting linebacker, then a J-Back in Chris Creighton's offense. He excelled at every position he played, and was voted team MVP his Junior season.
RB
Drew Lauer (2019) --Overcame injuries to put it all together in his final year: 1,127 rushing yards and 233 receiving yards. Edged out his predecessor, Conley Wilkins.
OL
Evan Lawrence (2010) --Two time All-PFL 1st teamer at right tackle.
OL
Ryan Lemke (2017) --Started over two seasons. 1st Team All-PFL as a Senior.
OL
Payson Wick (2017) --Started almost three seasons. Final season earned 1st Team all league. Honorable mention to Troy Witmer (2014).
OL
Avery Fuhs (2012) 1st team All-PFL as a guard. 1st team All-Hair Team as a tackle and guard.
OL
Aaron Melton-- (2016) After starting a season at guard, he missed a year due to injury. He then returned as a center, and was 1st team All-PFL.
TE
Eric Saubert (2016) --Created matchup nightmares for every opponent. Drafted by the NFL Falcons.
WR
Devin Cates (2019) --Mostly a wideout at Drake, before switching to tight end his final year. Another mismatch creator, Devin's pass catching skills improved over his last dozen games.
WR
Steven Doran (2019) --FCS top-ten in touchdowns scored during his Junior year.
Defense
DL Dain Taylor (2010)--2nd team FCS All-American. 27.5 career sacks.DL
Matt Acree--(2014) Four year starter. 1st team All-PFL as a Senior.
DL
Nathan Clayberg (2018) --PFL Defensive Player of the Year.
DL
Mack Marrin (2014)--1st Team all league as a Sophmore. He missed many games with injuries. Otherwise, he was a four-year starter.
LB
Tyler Moorehead (2012)--PFL Defensive Player of the Year.
LB
John Hugunin (2015)--Led the league in tackles his Senior year (113).
LB
Kieran Sierra (2018)--Led the 2018 team in tackles. Sealed his place on this list with big plays in the Iowa State game. Honorable mention to teammate Zac Rujawitz, who (like Lauer) was a St. Louis area recruit who had a big finish.
DB
Michael Lahart (2011) --Began as a running back, then became one of the best corners in Drake's nonscholarship era. Great on special teams. Great student.
DB
Sean Lynch (2018)--Started over two seasons. 1st team All-PFL as a Junior. Honorable mention: Mike Ratelle (2011).
DB
Will Warner--Although he won't finish until the next decade, he makes the team for his All-America season in 2018.
DB
Jabari Butler (2018)--1st team All-PFL. Best coverage cornerback during his years at Drake.
Kickers
PK
Josh Lee (2016) PFL Special Teams Player of the Year.
P
Cam Bohnert (2014) Averaged nearly 40 yards per kick during his Junior year.